Research letter · JAMA Network Open · 2023
Mental Health Questions on State Medical License Applications and Evaluation of Updates
Douglas RN, Sharpe EE, Kraus M, Saddawi‑Konefka D, Hanson AC, Pulos B. doi:10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2023.33360
The question
Many physicians avoid mental health care because they fear it could cost them their medical license. In 2014 the US Department of Justice found that, to comply with the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA), professional licensing boards must limit mental health questions to current diagnoses that impair an applicant's ability to do their job. In 2018 the Federation of State Medical Boards (FSMB) released 4 recommendations for license applications. Boards should ask only about impairment, ask only about current conditions, allow "safe haven" nonreporting, and include supportive language that normalizes physician wellness.
Earlier work, including a 2021 study by Saddawi‑Konefka and colleagues, looked at initial license applications. This study, with first author Douglas and corresponding author Pulos, both at Mayo Clinic, looked mainly at renewal applications, which the authors believe had not been assessed this way before. It also compared initial and renewal applications within each state and measured how initial applications had changed since 2020.
What it found
Between March and December 2022, two authors collected and scored initial and renewal applications from 55 allopathic medical licensing boards (all 50 states, Washington, DC, and 4 US territories), using the methods of the 2021 study.
- Only 3 renewal applications (5%) met all 4 recommendations. Twenty-eight (51%) met 3, 12 (22%) met 2, 9 (16%) met 1, and 3 (5%) met none.
- Fewer renewal applications than initial applications met the "only if impaired" recommendation (40 of 55 [73%] vs 47 of 55 [85%]).
- Renewal applications more often offered safe haven nonreporting (33 of 55 [60%] vs 23 of 55 [42%]) and more often asked only about current conditions (49 of 55 [89%] vs 46 of 55 [84%]).
- Compared with 2020, more initial applications in 2022 asked only about impairment (85% vs 72%) and only about current conditions (84% vs 76%). Fewer offered safe haven nonreporting (42% vs 46%) or included supportive language (13% vs 15%).
Why it matters
The authors describe consistency of renewal applications with the FSMB recommendations as low, particularly for safe haven nonreporting and supportive language. Initial and renewal applications from the same state often differed, and the authors see fixing these within-state differences as a straightforward opportunity to support physician mental health care.
They describe progress since 2020 as mixed. Gains on the impairment and current-condition recommendations may reflect attention to ADA compliance. The authors are concerned that safe haven nonreporting and supportive language had not improved, because they regard reducing stigma as critical to removing barriers to care.
It reviewed the text of applications between March and December 2022, and some may have changed while the review was under way.
How to cite it
Douglas RN, Sharpe EE, Kraus M, Saddawi-Konefka D, Hanson AC, Pulos B. Mental health questions on state medical license applications and evaluation of updates. JAMA Netw Open. 2023;6(9):e2333360. doi:10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2023.33360
More on the publications page. The complete record is on PubMed and ORCID.