Research letter · JAMA · 2021
Consistency Between State Medical License Applications and Recommendations Regarding Physician Mental Health
Saddawi‑Konefka D, Brown A, Eisenhart I, Hicks K, Barrett E, Gold JA. doi:10.1001/jama.2021.2275
The question
Physicians have higher rates of depression, burnout, and suicide than the general population, yet they seldom seek mental health care, and they consistently cite fear of consequences for their medical license as a reason. Many state medical license applications ask broad questions about a physician's mental health history or about how a condition might hypothetically affect their competence. The authors note that asking these questions violates the Americans With Disabilities Act, and earlier research found that physicians in states whose applications ask them are more reluctant to seek help.
In 2018 the Federation of State Medical Boards (FSMB), an umbrella organization that advises state medical boards, published recommendations on physician wellness and burnout. Saddawi‑Konefka and colleagues asked how closely state license applications followed the recommendations that apply to them.
What it found
In July 2020 the team collected the publicly available initial license applications from all 50 states, Washington, DC, Guam, the Northern Mariana Islands, and the US Virgin Islands, 54 in all. Four of the FSMB's 10 recommendations could be checked on an application. Two authors coded each application, a third settled disagreements, and each state received a score from 0 to 4.
- Seventeen states (31%) asked no questions that could require disclosing a mental health condition. The study counted these states as consistent with the first three recommendations below, so they are included in those three counts.
- Thirty-nine states (72%) were consistent with the "only if impaired" recommendation (if mental health questions are asked, they are limited to conditions causing impairment).
- Forty-one (76%) were consistent with the "only current" recommendation (if questions are asked, they are limited to conditions within the last 2 years).
- Twenty-five (46%) were consistent with the "safe haven nonreporting" recommendation. Safe haven nonreporting lets physicians who are monitored by and in good standing with a Physician Health Program leave out diagnoses or treatment history.
- Only 8 states (15%) included supportive or normalizing language about seeking mental health care. Five states were consistent with none of the four recommendations and only 1 was consistent with all four. The mean score was 2.1.
Why it matters
The number of states that asked no mental health questions, or asked only about current impairment, suggests improvement over earlier reports. A 2017 report had found that 21 of 51 states (41%) limited questions to current conditions with impairment. Even so, most states had not fully adopted the FSMB recommendations, and the authors conclude that license applications may continue to deter physicians from seeking mental health care. They also point out that the COVID-19 pandemic had increased physicians' need for that care.
It is a snapshot of initial license applications as of July 2020; renewal applications were not reviewed.
How to cite it
Saddawi-Konefka D, Brown A, Eisenhart I, Hicks K, Barrett E, Gold JA. Consistency between state medical license applications and recommendations regarding physician mental health. JAMA. 2021;325(19):2017-2018. doi:10.1001/jama.2021.2275
More on the publications page. The complete record is on PubMed and ORCID.