Randomized trial · Journal of Graduate Medical Education · 2017
Changing Resident Physician Studying Behaviors: A Randomized, Comparative Effectiveness Trial of Goal Setting Versus Use of WOOP
Saddawi‑Konefka D, Baker K, Guarino A, Burns SM, Oettingen G, Gollwitzer PM, Charnin JE. doi:10.4300/JGME-D-16-00703.1
The question
Following through on goals to study can be hard for residents, given clinical demands and limited personal time. This study tested a brief exercise called WOOP (Wish, Outcome, Obstacle, Plan), known in psychology research as mental contrasting with implementation intentions. A person using WOOP names a meaningful goal, imagines the best outcome of reaching it, identifies and imagines the main inner obstacle, and then makes an “if-then” plan to overcome that obstacle. WOOP had increased follow-through on goals in many other fields, but to the authors’ knowledge it had not been evaluated in medical education. The study asked whether it would lead residents to spend more time studying toward their goals than goal setting alone.
Saddawi‑Konefka and colleagues ran the trial from March to August 2015 with anesthesiology residents in their second through fourth postgraduate years, during a one-month intensive care unit (ICU) rotation at Massachusetts General Hospital. All 34 eligible residents took part. Groups were assigned by rotation month to reduce the chance of the strategy spreading between groups. Sixteen residents were in the WOOP group and 18 in the goal-setting group, and residents did not know which group they were in. Everyone received the same organized collection of articles on 12 ICU topics and chose 3. The comparison group heard a talk on goal setting and was encouraged to make goals that were specific, actionable, and achievable, and the WOOP group used WOOP instead, each within 30 minutes. Residents then logged their study time in daily diaries for three weeks.
What it found
The primary outcome was total time spent studying toward the residents’ stated goals.
- Residents in the WOOP group studied toward their goals for a median of 4.3 hours over the three weeks, compared with 1.5 hours in the goal-setting group (P = .021). The effect size (Hedges’ g = 0.66) falls in the range the authors describe as medium to large.
- A larger share of WOOP residents reported any goal-directed studying in each week after the intervention (81%, 69%, and 81% in weeks 1 to 3, versus 50%, 56%, and 44%; odds ratio 3.32, P = .005). This yes-or-no analysis was meant to limit the effect of overestimated study time.
- Time spent studying medical material unrelated to the goals, a secondary outcome, did not differ between groups (median 5.5 hours with WOOP and 5.0 hours with goal setting, P = .99).
- Satisfaction with reading habits and with time management fell over the month in the goal-setting group and did not change in the WOOP group. The difference between groups in that change was statistically significant for time management (P = .044) and not for reading habits (P = .07).
Why it matters
Training residents to use WOOP took less than 30 minutes and had no additional costs. The size of the effect was consistent with studies of WOOP in other domains, and the added goal-directed studying did not come at the cost of time spent on other medical material. The authors conclude that WOOP may be a useful strategy for increasing self-regulated learning by residents, meaning learning that residents select, manage, and evaluate on their own.
The trial included 34 residents in one program, followed for three weeks, so the results may not generalize to other programs or settings.
How to cite it
Saddawi-Konefka D, Baker K, Guarino A, et al. Changing resident physician studying behaviors: a randomized, comparative effectiveness trial of goal setting versus use of WOOP. J Grad Med Educ. 2017;9(4):451-457. doi:10.4300/JGME-D-16-00703.1
More on the publications page. The complete record is on PubMed and ORCID.