Perspective · Anesthesia & Analgesia · In press
Expertise by Design: Why Modern Training Requires Deliberate Cultivation
Nizamuddin J, Baker K, Ambardekar A, Saddawi‑Konefka D. doi:10.1213/ANE.0000000000008191
The question
Anesthesiology has become far safer. The article notes mortality rates as high as 1 in 2000 in the early decades and perioperative mortality rates below 1 in 100,000 today. Work hour limits protect residents, training cultures are more humane, competency frameworks set minimum standards, and technology supports clinical decisions. The authors treat each of these as genuine progress. They argue that, taken together, these changes have reshaped the learning environment in ways that erode the cognitive conditions needed to develop adaptive expertise, which they define as the capacity to improvise, synthesize, and exercise judgment when protocols fail, situations are new, or technology is unavailable. They distinguish it from routine competence, the ability to perform well under familiar conditions using established procedures.
What it argues
This is a perspective article. It reports no new data and draws on research in cognitive science and medical education, along with the authors’ own experience leading residency programs.
- The authors describe four conditions for expertise. These are knowledge organized into a cognitive architecture built through effortful encoding, reflection supported by continuity and feedback, deliberate practice at the edge of current ability, and a mature relationship with knowledge and uncertainty.
- They argue that modern training reduces each one. Protocols, decision support, artificial intelligence (AI) tools, and instant information can let a novice skip the reasoning that builds knowledge. Handoffs under work hour limits make it harder to see the consequences of one’s decisions, and pressure for operating room throughput leaves little time for debriefing. Perceived medicolegal pressures and production pressures can lead attendings to take over early. Many faculty have become reluctant to give direct critique.
- They argue that heavy reliance on multiple-choice exams and question banks rewards recognizing answers over reasoning, and that competency-based medical education, by naming competence as the outcome, risks signaling that adequacy is the goal.
- They cite evidence that experience alone does not produce expertise, including a systematic review in which physician performance decreased with more years of experience in over half of 62 studies.
- They propose changes at four levels. Learners can form their own plans before consulting decision support and critically check AI output. Educators can ask residents to state their plans first and model saying “I don’t know, but here’s how I’m thinking about it.” Programs can prioritize case ownership, debriefing, and mentorship. The specialty can expand oral exams and frame competence as the floor from which expertise is built.
Why it matters
The authors state that they are not arguing for a return to training that was less safe for patients or less humane for trainees. Their case is that the gains of recent decades can be kept while the conditions that expertise requires are rekindled through deliberate design. The article pairs specific threats with restorative strategies for each of the four conditions and organizes the strategies by who can act, from individual learners to national organizations.
How to cite it
Nizamuddin J, Baker K, Ambardekar A, Saddawi-Konefka D. Expertise by design: why modern training requires deliberate cultivation. Anesth Analg. Published online ahead of print 2026. doi:10.1213/ANE.0000000000008191
More on the publications page. The complete record is on PubMed and ORCID.